Martin Malone

my home on the web

Month: March 2019

Cheltenham 2019 – Friday

Thursday turned out to be one of the great days of recent Cheltenhams with excitement and big stories throughout the afternoon. We got off to a good start with Defi Du Seuil (3/1) and followed up with Paisley Park (2/1) and (most pleasing) Siruh Du Lac (8/1 when initially advised). Ladies Day was delayed by 24 hours this year with Lizzie Kelly’s win on Siruh Du Lac and, most significantly, Bryony Frost’s thrilling win on Frodon in the Grade 1 Ryanair (the first woman to win a Grade 1 at the Festival).

So, on to Friday and another great card. The ground is holding up very well (Willie Mullins said that both Un De Sceaux and Footpad needed it softer) and it seems that the wind is drying the rainfall with no significant changes expected for tomorrow. The times have indicated genuine soft ground but more on the good than the heavy side. This militates against soft/heavy specialists but means that we can take most of the form at face value, as demonstrated by the spate of favourites winning, based on their performances this season.

I’ve been following French website Equidia (who provide live coverage of the Festival in France) throughout the week and it’s been notable how, time after time, they’ve been pointing out that the winners have been French bred. You will see that theme in what follows.

13:30 Triumph Hurdle

Sir Erec – 4/5f

Embed from Getty Images

This one was a very good flat horse for Coolmore, placed behind Stradivarius in the Group 2 Long Distance Cup at Ascot and exceptionally well bred (by Camelot out of a Galileo mare). He’s taken very well to jumping although it’s worth noting that his trainer Joseph O’Brien said that he had the run of the race when winning last time out at the Dublin Racing Festival. It’s reasonable to assume that he won’t have such an easy time of it in this race. Joseph also noted that Pic D’Orhy has very good French form. He has a Timeform rating of 167p (courtesy of racingtv.com)

Gardens Of Babylon – 8/1

Embed from Getty Images

I mention this one only because of his place as second favourite in the betting. Also trained by Joseph O’Brien and in the same ownership (J P McManus) I see no reason for him to reverse the form, having been beaten by 6 lengths by Sir Erec when last seen out.

Pic D’Orhy – 9/1

This is an intriguing horse, making his UK debut for Paul Nicholls after performing at the highest level for Francois Nicolle, exclusively at Auteuil. His trainer describes him as “a gorgeous horse”, “a proper horse” and Timeform clearly agree with their rating of 166, just 1lb behind the favourite.

Quel Destin*** – 10/1 – selection

Embed from Getty Images

This is probably my favourite horse of the season, although it’s a close run thing with Paisley Park. Imported from Guy Cherel last September, he has had the ideal preparation including two Grade 2s and a Grade 1 and is the epitome of a tough National Hunt horse. He has nothing to prove and, for me, is a confident selection at an excellent price (my only ante-post bet placed several weeks ago but still great value). Timeform rated 159.

14:10 County Hurdle

I don’t have any strong views about this race so I will follow the positive words in previews for Whiskey Sour* (Mullins/Walsh), who is unsurprisingly the current 11/2f. He was third in this last year and appears to have been targeted to go two better this time. Of the others, I’m interested in Monsieur Lecoq (11/1), second in the Imperial Cup last Saturday, Capitaine (14/1), beneficiary of a wind op and subsequent winner last time out and Countister (16/1), one of my selections last year when fifth in the Dawn Run last year, but hasn’t been seen since then so it’s another leap of faith.

14:50 Albert Bartlett Novices’ Hurdle (“The Potato Race”)

3m (or, for pedants like me, 2m 7f 213y) is a long way for novices, so we’re looking for a confirmed stayer, particularly on softish ground. This is a race in which this year’s form on unusually good ground could make a difference. I think that this one could produce a long odds winner.

The current favourite is Birchdale (6/1 > 9/2). I think that he’s a hype horse because of the connections (Henderson/JP) and I don’t think that his form is anything special.

Commander Of Fleet (15/2 > 13/2) is second favourite. Gordon Elliott’s comments about him are illuminating. At the Betfair preview he said that he’s brilliant on the track but hopeless at home, adding that it is hard to be confident about him and saying he could be first or last.

Lisnaghar Oscar is OK and has a better Timeform rating than the favourite but not one for me at all.

Dickie Diver* (8/1) is one that will relish the trip but, again, is in the same ownership and with the same trainer as the favourite. I suppose that they wouldn’t mind which one wins and presumably wouldn’t be running him unless they thought that he had a chance. However, I should emphasise that this is a random choice, even by my standards!

Joseph O’Brien rates Rhinestone (12/1) as having an each way chance and rates Gordon Elliott’s Dinons (10/1), as do I (e/w), particularly with Davy Russell on board.

15:30 The Gold Cup

Presenting Percy – 4/1f

Embed from Getty Images

The enigma, and that covers both the horse and even more so the trainer. This has been a properly weird build-up. He ran three times in 2017, three times in 2018 and is chasing a three-timer at the Festival (Pertemps 2017, RSA 2018). He was beaten by Our Duke in the Red Mills in 2018 but that was probably over an inadequate trip (2m 4f). He’s won over 3m 5f on soft so his staying credentials are not in doubt. But, and it’s a big but, he’s had only one outing this year, over hurdles, and I’m not buying into the idea that this is a genius strategy. He could have run in two decent chases, including a repeat opportunity in the Red Mills, but didn’t. My take on that is that the horse needs properly soft ground and we haven’t got that (previous runs soft/soft/heavy/heavy/soft/soft-heavy). Could well win easily but will not have my money.

Native River – 4/1 > 9/2

Embed from Getty Images

In the same way as with Presenting Percy, I’m unconvinced that the ground is sufficiently soft for him to prevail at the highest level this time. It’s very hard to follow up on Gold Cup wins and, with the best will in the world, he’s not a Kauto Star or Best Mate.

Clan Des Obeaux** – 4/1 > 5/1 – selection

Embed from Getty Images

There’s no way that I would have selected this horse, even a week ago. However, I’ve been strongly influenced by the times of the races for the last three days (particularly on the New Course on Thursday) and there’s no doubt that he has the best profile, based on this season’s performances. I accept that there’s really nothing to go on with Presenting Percy but his King George win can’t be ignored and he has won on Haydock heavy over 2m 5f. Will he stay? I’m not absolutely convinced but he is, in my view, the best horse in the race and Nicholls’ current form can’t be ignored.

Bellshill – 10/1 > 8/1

Embed from Getty Images

I can see exactly why this one has attracted support, including from my shrewd friend Gerry Rooney, who notes that he’s Ruby’s selection ahead of the one Ruby previously hinted at, Al Boum Photo. Two of his last three outings include wins in the Punchestown and Irish Gold Cups but, in between, he was beaten by Kemboy, Monlaee (4th in the Ryanair) and Road To Respect (3rd in the Ryanair). WP is desperate for a Gold Cup winner but I don’t see this one delivering it for him, albeit I can well see him running into a place.

Kemboy – 11/1

Embed from Getty Images

This one is probably a stayer and won the Savills Chase. David Mullins keeps the ride but, for me, his jumping is against him and I don’t see him as top level.

Al Boum Photo – 12/1

Embed from Getty Images

Another one that is just not top level.

Might Bite – 12/1

Embed from Getty Images

Nicky Henderson and Nico de Boinville both reported that he ran very well in his racecourse gallop but there’s no way that he can be supported based on his proper races this season.

Elegant Escape – 16/1

Embed from Getty Images

I’ve gone this far down the field because staying is the game and I think that this one should not be ignored. 2nd in the Hennessy, winner of the Welsh National and 2nd to Frodon in the Cotswold Chase, he’ll be staying on, even on this ground, when many others have given up the ghost. A sound each way option.

Verdict

I’ve surprised myself by selecting Clan Des Obeaux but I’m keen on Elegant Escape usurping Native River as the place option.

16:10 Foxhunters’ Chase

In late February this is what I had to say and I see no reason to depart from it:

Recent pointer Stand Up And Fight, owned by J P McManus and trained by Enda Bolger, is the big talking horse and current favourite for this race at 3/1. As a 7-y-o he could be absolutely anything. My preference is currently for two proper campaigners, Ucello Conti (4/1), a very taking winner of the Navan hunters’ chase against good opponents on 17 February, and my current selection, Road To Rome(6/1), a superb winner of the Walrus at Haydock on 16 February, whose form following wind surgery is 24321111111. This will be former winner’s Pacha Du Polder’s last race so I’m just hoping for a safe round for that one. Another that I’ll keep an eye out for is Shantou Flyer (7/1) who appears to have found his metier with new owner and man of the Hunters David Maxwell.

28 February 2019

So, now we are at the night before and the odds are:

  • Ucello Conti 7/2
  • Stand Up And Fight 4/1
  • Hazel Hill 11/2
  • Caid Du Berlais 7/1
  • Road To Rome 8/1
  • Shantou Flyer 8/1
  • Pacha Du Polder 18/1

I’ll take the 8/1 Road To Rome*** thank you very much.

16:50 Grand Annual Chase

Embed from Getty Images

For me, the Festival finishes with the Foxhunters’ but I’ll put up selections for the remaining two races. Le Prezien* (9/1) is very well priced to repeat last year’s victory in this race.

17:30 Martin Pipe

Embed from Getty Images

This race has produced future Cheltenham stars and my idea of that one is 6-y-o Dallas Des Pictons** (11/4f) for Gordon Elliott. He’s made no secret of the fact that he loves to win this race and has put him up as his pick of the week. Bear in mind that this was when Apple’s Jade and co were still to run.


Cheltenham 2019 – Thursday

It was a better Wednesday with all selections for the last four races winning (admittedly all favourites). Altior was given a proper test, while bumper winner Envoi Allen looks very impressive.

On to Thursday and an excellent card from start to finish.

13:30 JLT Chase

Defi Du Seuil*** (3/1 > 5/2) would not have been on the radar for me at the start of the season, but has developed into a really good chaser. A former Triumph Hurdle winner, I think that this is his ideal distance and he’ll have the best of the ground in the first race on the New Course since New Year’s Day. He was second to Lostintranslation in January but beat him on his next outing at Sandown.

Real Steel is probably the best of the Willie Mullins trio but Ruby has chosen Voix Du Reve.

Kildisart (9/1) is the best of the rest and could be a big improver.

14:10 Pertemps Final

This is the usual lottery and the one that caught my eye is Joseph O’Brien’s Thermistocles* (12/1). He’s been aimed at this race.

I can see why Sire Du Berlais is the 9/2 favourite. Fourth in the Martin Pipe last year and although his last outing when sixth seemed to be a plan to get into this race, I’m not convinced with the reminder of his form.

First Assignment (12/1) has a very good profile, including a win at Cheltenham last October in a Class 3 hurdle when 9/2f.

14:50 Ryanair Chase

This is in my view the best Ryanair yet and one of the proper highlights of the week.

I was all against Footpad** (7/2 > 5/1) as a result of what has been a disappointing season, particularly given the heights reached last season. However, he was running well at Leopardstown when headed by Simply Ned in the Grade 1 chase on 27 December, having reportedly suffered an overreach when falling the previous month. I’m willing to take a chance that he’s back to his best, in which case he wins.

Road To Respect has attracted a lot of support and is current favourite at 7/2. A previous Festival winner (Brown Advisory Plate) in 2017 and fourth in the following year’s Gold Cup, this season he has won the JN Wine Champion Chase at Down Royal and ran well in the Savills Chase and the Irish Gold Cup at the Dublin Racing Festival so he clearly has a leading chance. The same can be said for Monalee (9/2), who has excellent credentials, second to Presenting Percy in last year’s RSA and won the Grade 2 Red Mills Chase last month over 2 1/2 miles which appears to be his ideal trip. They are both leading contenders and potential winners.

Un De Sceaux was second in this race and won in 2017. Although the ground will undoubtedly suit, I think that this is a step too far for the hard-campaigned 11-y-o (although I ‘d be delighted to be wrong!).

15:30 Stayers’ Hurdle

Another 11-y-o, Faugheen, is now the unlikely second favourite for this race at a fast contracting 7/2. For me, it takes a big leap of faith and you have to attach a lot to his defeat of last year’s winner of this race, Penhill, in the Punchestown Stayers’ Hurdle last April, when many thought that he was not faced with the toughest of challenges.

Paisley Park***** (2/1 > 7/4) is a horse that I’ve followed all season and has impeccable credentials for this race. He’s my only five star selection of the day and I’m looking forward to a dominant victory.

16:10 Brown Advisory Plate

Siruh Du Lac** (13/2) is one that I picked some time ago for this race.

16:50 Mares’ Novices’ Hurdle

Posh Trish**** (13/2 > 6/1) is my second best of the day and represents really good value.

17:30 Kim Muir

Measureofmydreams* (9/2 > 7/2) appears to have been plotted for this one and featured in all the Irish previews that I saw.

Good luck!

Cheltenham 2019 – Wednesday

First, hot off the press and disappointingly, Elixir De Nutz is lame and has been ruled out of the opening Supreme Hurdle on Tuesday. I might have a small bet on Vision D’honneur but only to have an interest.

On to Wednesday and the main news is that, although Santini is declared, Nicky Henderson sounded in a TV interview that he is far from convinced that he will run. I wouldn’t have been selecting him anyway and all the more so now.

The weather forecast is dreadful and if the winds are as strong as predicted, it’s not out of the question that there may be a repeat of the 2008 abandonment which succumbed to high winds which made the course unsafe as a result of the risk of damage to temporary structures and advertising boards. For reference, the wind speed that day was 50mph. According to the Met Office, the wind on Wednesday is forecast to reach up to 49mph at midday and 43mph at 3.00 p.m. Let’s hope it goes ahead.

13:30 Ballymore Hurdle

Embed from Getty Images

I don’t have a particularly strong view about this race. According to the betting it’s a head to head between Champ (5/2) and Battleoverdoyen (100/30). I’m going with the latter. Gordon Elliott has a very high opinion of him. He’s unbeaten and won a Grade 1 well last time out in January. He’s yet to prove form on this likely ground but I suspect it might be a benefit (Elliott pulled him out of his intended race at the Dublin Racing Festival on account of unsuitable good ground).

14:10 RSA Chase

Embed from Getty Images

As mentioned above, I can’t have Santini (100/30), given the interrupted preparation and questions about his wellbeing. Topofthegame (100/30) has been beaten by two top class horses this season in the shape of Defi Du Seuil and La Bague Au Roi, but last won a Grade 3 hurdle as long ago as February 2018.

My idea of the winner is Delta Work (15/8), a fine horse, unbeaten in three outings this season (including two Grade 1s and a victory over highly rated Le Richebourg). He won the Pertemps on soft ground at the Festival last year and should have no problem staying in what is likely to be an even tougher race than usual.

14:50 Coral Cup

Embed from Getty Images

Just a quick each way selection in this one and it’s Bleu Berry (20/1), winner of this on soft ground last year and not disgraced when fourth in a Grade 2 and third in the Grade 1 Punchestown Champion Hurdle. His only outing this year was when very highly tried in the Galmoy Hurdle at Gowran (seventh behind Presenting Percy). Looks well primed for this one.

15:30 Champion Chase

Embed from Getty Images

This is an opportunity to take time out from betting and just enjoy the peerless Altior (4/9)

16:10 Cross Country

Embed from Getty Images

Tiger Roll (6/5) was very impressive when winning the Grade 2 Boyne Hurdle in February. He was not expected to do anything in that race and went off at 25/1. He appears to be in rude health and this Grand National winner should repeat last year’s victory. Of the others, course and distance winner Urgent De Gregaine for French trainer Emmanuel Clayeux is a very fair price at 14/1.

16:50 Boodles Fred Winter

Just a quick selection and it’s favourite (sorry) Band Of Outlaws (13/2) for Joseph O’Brien. This one was well talked up in the previews.

17:30 Champion Bumper

Embed from Getty Images

In my February preview I identified Envoi Allen (100/30) as a serious horse. Gordon Elliott said that he’s one of the two or three best in his yard and that’s good enough for me.

Good luck!

Cheltenham 2019 – Tuesday

Here we are at last! The Festival is about 40 hours away as I’m writing and, as ever, I can’t wait for the feast of racing that will keep me fully occupied for the next five days (including Cheltenham Eve!).

First things first – the weather. As I mentioned in my post at the end of February, the ground is a massive factor and Accuweather pretty much nailed it in terms of the forecast. Clerk of the course, Simon Claisse, is currently predicting soft ground for day one and, based on the hailstorm that I’m watching as I’m typing this, I’m expecting that it will be nearer soft to heavy rather than good to soft. That makes a massive difference. For a normal Cheltenham you need horses that stay, because of the pace of the races and the hill. On soft ground that is even more to the fore and, with a major storm and 50mph winds forecast for Wednesday, could be even more important later in the week (Un De Sceaux and Native River immediately spring to mind). It’s a time to be cautious about graduates from the flat, and to favour National Hunt bred horses and particularly those from France, which conveniently suits my favoured profile!

Returning to my preview post, I’m pleased that my initial selections for day one are unchanged (that will not be the case for the rest of the week!). So, on to the races themselves and, once again, thank goodness for the 48 hour declarations

13.30 Supreme Novices’ Hurdle

Embed from Getty Images

5/1 the field is an appetising starter for the first of 28 races and here are my views about the leading candidates.

Al Dancer (5/1 jf)

Yet to be beaten over hurdles, he was an impressive winner of the Betfair Hurdle at Ascot on 16 February, but he didn’t beat much. This is good handicap form and he might be seen as following in the line of Kalashnikov, a similar handicap winner before going close in this one last year. His previous outing was in a Class 3 on the new course at Cheltenham (old course this time) and, again, he didn’t beat much. He’s been declared without a hood (which he’s worn on his previous outings) and, when asked today about it, jockey Sam Twiston-Davies said that they’re going for ear plugs instead. An odd selection for the hubbub of the Festival. Not for me.

Angels Breath (5/1 jf)

This is definitively not one for me. Much hyped (no doubt because of the trainer/owner combination – Henderson/Dai Walters), his much delayed follow up to the Grade 2 Kennel Gate at Ascot in December (when four of the eight hurdles were omitted) was when he was beaten by unheralded Southfield Stone in the Dovecote at Kempton on 23 February. Some have said that he was unsuited by the good ground and fast track but I think that’s more about wanting to believe rather than analysing the cold facts.

Klassical Dream (6/1)

Currently attracting support, this winner of a maiden hurdle at the Leopardstown Christmas meeting followed up with a victory by a head over my selection of the day Aramon at the Dublin Racing Festival on 3 February. I was there and felt that this one is not top class. To be fair, much vaunted Vision D’honneur was third but I’m not convinced that soft ground at Cheltenham will suit.

Fakir D’oudairies (13/2)

An impressive winner of the Triumph Hurdle Trial on the new course on good to soft ground at Cheltenham on 26 January, again not beating too many good ones (second was 25/1), I thought that this one would be one of my Festival favourites. However, it’s pretty obvious that this 4-y-o (no 4-y-o has won this race for 20 years) is turning up here because another JP horse (and possibly most backed of the week), Sir Erec, is the favourite for the Triumph. Could run a screamer but I doubt it.

Elixir De Nutz (8/1) – selection

And now on to my selection, the well-campaigned and highly exciting Elixir De Nutz. I’ve followed him throughout the season to date. Beaten on his seasonal outing in a Class 3 over the course by Thomas Darby, he’s not looked back since. Won the Supreme Trial on the old course on 18 November, followed up (on the old course) on 14 December and won a good Tolworth on soft at Sandown on 5 January. Hard as nails and will win.

Grand Sancy (12/1)

A good French horse but beaten by Elixir De Nutz. Subsequently won the Kingwell at Wincanton but I don’t see him reversing the form with my selection, particularly on the ground.

14:10 Arkle Novices’ Chase

Embed from Getty Images

This is much more open than recent renewals but, again, I have a firm selection.

Glen Forsa (9/2f) – selection

This is exceptional value. Sometimes (quite rarely) you see one horse break another’s heart and that is exactly what I saw when this one beat 1/4f Kalashnikov at the relocated Kingmaker at Sandown on soft on 15 February. Admittedly it was a three horse race and the third made up the numbers but this was a majestic jumping performance for a novice, in a style very reminiscent of Footpad last year. Put simply, he is this year’s Footpad and my bet of the day.

Lalor (4/1)

It’s easy to be heart over head with this horse. He won well over this course in the Grade 2 Arkle Trial (Defi Du Seuil was last) on good ground but his run in the Henry VIII at Sandown in December on soft was desperately disappointing. I would want to have seen him redeem that outing in the meantime before I could support him in this one

Hardline (6/1)

This one has stormed up the betting since being highlighted in several Cheltenham previews. I think that he’s the best of a moderate Irish bunch and being put up precisely for that reason. I watched him being comprehensively beaten by La Bague Au Roi in Dublin on 3 February and I just don’t get the hype.

14:50 Ultima Handicap Steeplechase

Embed from Getty Images

Unlike the first two, I don’t have a strong view about this race. Current favourite Give Me A Copper (11/2) for Paul Nicholls was well beaten last time out on soft ground at Sandown. Minella Rocco (8/1) will never be a selection for me. Mister Whitaker (also 8/1) won the Close Bros Novices last year and I think that is the only reason why he is towards the head of the betting. I’m going to rely on what I’ve heard in the preview nights (and from Barry Orr today) and have an each way on Lake View Lad at an appealing 20/1. Other each way options are Beware The Bear (20/1) and Royal Vacation (soft ground stayer – 25/1).

15:30 Champion Hurdle

Embed from Getty Images

This is the best Champion Hurdle for years and is between the first three, with one notable outsider.

Apple’s Jade (2/1f) – selection

Ignore her run in the Mares’ Hurdle last year – she was in season and obviously didn’t run to form. She will not be in season this year (I have no idea how or why that is the case but that’s what I’ve heard!) and her form, that run aside, is impeccable.

Buveur D’air (9/4)

Looking for a third consecutive Champion Hurdle, whether you like him or not, I agree with Matt Chapman that the last two were by no means classics. He only beat Melon by a neck last year and the defeat at the hands of Paloma Blue in the Christmas Hurdle in December was significant. This one is often mentioned in the same breath as the other Henderson star Altior but the Champion Chaser is a significantly better horse.

Laurina (4/1)

Unbeaten since transferring from Guillaume Macaire to Willie Mullins in November 2017 and with (mares only) winning form on soft and heavy, she could be a very good horse. However, I’m inclined to attach an awful lot of weight to jockey Ruby Walsh’s one line assessment of her, that “she’ll need to improve”.

Espoir D’allen (20/1)

Although I don’t see this one as a winner, the profile is great (unbeaten this season in three Grade 3s including the Limestone Lad last time out) and I could easily see him running into a place in what is currently a 10 runner race.

16:10 Mares’ Hurdle

Embed from Getty Images

I see this as a head to head between Benie Des Dieux (5/6) and Lady Buttons (9/1). In the absence of the main challengers (Apple’s Jade and Laurina) this is an easily winnable race. I selected Benie Des Dieux last month and I see no reason to change. She won this last year and the form of Lady Buttons is just not quite good enough. I was a big fan of Stormy Ireland last year but she didn’t live up to expectations. One for a place at 50/1 is Alletrix.

16:50 Close Brothers Novices’ Chase

I have no interest in this race whatsoever, but will mention that in the preview nights there was support for Tower Bridge (8/1) for J P O’Brien.

17:30 National Hunt Amateurs’ Novices’ Chase (the four miler)

Although trained by Nicky Henderson and ridden by Derek O’Connor, I really don’t like current favourite Ok Corral (3/1). The form is at best dubious, although I realise that could be a plot. I have been reluctantly convinced by several pundits at Cheltenham preview nights that there is perhaps a better plot in the shape of Discorama (7/1) . The difference with this one is that he ran into a good fifth in the Grade 1 Drinmore (beaten by among others Delta Work and Le Richebourg) and has never run over anything like this distance. He also has form on yielding, soft and (to a lesser extent) heavy.

Summary

So the leading selections are:

  • Supreme – Elixir De Nutz
  • Arkle – Glen Forsa
  • Champion – Apple’s Jade
  • Mares’ – Benie Des Dieux

An accumulator will deliver 221/1 and the Lucky 15 £622 so a £2 accumulator and £15 Lucky 15 delivers a potential maximum of £1067. Good luck!!

© 2019 Martin Malone

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑